Postmodernism has served me well.
Through my artistic and personal life, I could say and do pretty much anything I wanted and hide behind the po-mo shield. This has been particularly handy when feeling some pretty deep and scary emotions. Earnestness, I mean true earnestness, gives me the “Godfrey moist eye.” As articulated in a previous post, I’m a crier.
But I’ve been going through a bit of a transformation lately — trying to showcase a more serious Scotty. But here’s the punchline (because there always is a punchline): my newfound earnestness has been brought out through the writing and recording of an album. Okay, it’s a…um…concept album.
If you don’t get what makes this so absurd, let me spell it out for you: in my estimation, there’s little that one could do in our current cultural and technological landscape that would be more ridiculously ironic, self-indulgent, and culturally limp than to write a concept album.
I mean, who has the time or wherewithal anymore to sit and listen to an entire album? Because that’s what you’re supposed to do every time you unsheath a concept album — listen to the whole thing. Think of my endeavor as akin to saying, “Damn the Internet! I’m writing and releasing a set of hardcover encyclopedias.” Or, “I know that it sounds like a bad idea — considering that 82% of Americans own cell phones — but I’m investing my lifesavings in a payphone company.” Simply put, the concept album is a relic of a bygone era — an outmoded technology.
And what, you may ask, do people who traditionally make concept albums look like?

Or this:

At any rate, they don’t normally look like this:

Also, one might wonder if it was a coincidence that while researching other concept albums for this post I noticed that several prog-rock websites carry advertisements for mail-order brides. As a friend of mine once said when describing his mid-’80s prog escapades: “hot licks and no chicks.” True story: I’ve known only one woman to ever own a Rush album — I married her.
For those too young or disinterested to have been exposed, here’s a smattering of some of the more notable concept albums of yore:
Pink Floyd’s The Wall:

The story of a self-isolated rock star who ultimately imagines himself as a fascist monster, The Wall is, notably, the only number-one selling album to include a scene in which a giant ass defecates on the protagonist — quite an accomplishment.
Rush’s 2112 (side one anyway):

The futuristic story of an intergalactic federation of quasi-religious rulers (the Priests of the Temple of Syrinx) who govern the people’s thoughts through legislating what art they can view, hear, or read. (Anyone have any experience dealing with the NEA? Lane?)
The Who’s Tommy:

You all know the story: he’s deaf; he’s dumb; he’s blind, “but he sure plays a mean pinball!”. ‘Nuff said.
Hüsker Dü’s Zen Arcade:

The elusive story of a disaffected youth who runs away from home only to find that the outside world is even more fucked than his parents — “Turn on the news,” indeed!
Genesis’ The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway:

The surreal story of a shirtless young man who encounters any amount of crazy shit while looking for his brother in a subway system (think Clash of the Titans on really speedy acid).
Yes, I know that there are a bunch of others, but these give what I think is a good beginners’ sonic and genre sampling. And believe me, the last thing I want to do is spark another Bowie debate by including Ziggy Stardust on the list.
For those familiar with the above works, do you notice a trend among them? They’re all pretty darn earnest — okay, extremely earnest, and thus, quite laughable (which isn’t to say that I’m not a fan).
Besides bringing out my serious side, writing my concept album has been an altogether different kind of experience from other projects that I’ve undertaken. Sonically, I’ve written it as one might compile a mixtape; I think about what kind of song I’d want to hear following the last. So if the previous song was all quiet and mellow, I’m likely to try to write a song that has a little kick to it, and vice versa.
The other part that’s been interesting is having essentially self-imposed assignments; because I’m writing along a narrative arc, there are certain plot points that I’ve needed to fill in. In other words, for the narrative to work, I’ve needed to write songs in which certain events take place.
But here’s my favorite part of the experience: in an extreme twist of postmodern irony, it has been my adherence to po-mo that’s given me the ability to take such an absurd project so fucking earnestly. As my views have evolved into a somewhat creative form of Nihilism, I’ve come to believe that if nothing matters, everything matters, even a concept album, which the world really needs right now.


This post is so interesting – It spurred several thoughts (aside from the fact that it is very entertaining).
I have been thinking about these sorts of ideas as I witness the musical behavior of “kids today.” I have long lamented the loss of the album format as something you put on and listen from beginning to end. Even if it wasn’t a concept album, you were imagining the links from song to song by the 347th playing. What occured me the other day is that in a weird way they are building their own concepts albums in their mixes – which they are obssessed by.
I am also intrigued by the difference between opera and concept albums – an arching narrative made of individual songs.
And I will also be thinking today about: “As my views have evolved into a somewhat creative form of Nihilism, I’ve come to believe that if nothing matters, everything matters, even a concept album, which the world really needs right now.” That is a really really great line.
Concept ablbums are great, and this album that you’re making sounds pretty amazing, too. I had no idea you did music. Will you be sampling some of it here? Because I would love to take a listen.
We are the priiiiiiieeeeeessts of the temmmmmples of Syyyyrinx!
You know two women who own Rush albums.
Yesterday I was reading a description of Das Rheingold, the first opera in Wagner’s “Ring” cycle. It’s so freakin’ like a concept album, it’s a little out of hand. No one was as earnest as Germans in the 19th century.
I, too, love your point that when nothing matters at all, everything matters. It’s the post-post-modern!
Also, maybe it’s just the handlebar ‘stache, but doesn’t Neil Peart in the above photo resemble
Greg Norton of Husker Du?
Scotty, maybe you should grow one of those for the album cover photo shoot.
No one was as earnest as Germans in the 19th century.
No one was as emo as Germans in the late 18th century.
No one was as Goth as Germans in the third and fourth centuries.
No one was as gay-looking as German ladies in the late 20th century.
8: Sorry, lame. Try again.
Don’t blame me. Blame these people.
“I’ve come to believe that if nothing matters, everything matters,”
a star is born.
You ARE gonna put it out on vinyl, right? ‘Cause if it’s not on vinyl, it doesn’t count as a concept album. I’m just sayin’.
Parrish, other than the obvious reasons, I knew there was a reason why I love you so much.
J-Man: one step at a time. I first need to get the thing done, but I’m pretty darn close.
As for the opera/concept album thing: though I have a strong narrative in mind, I am going for a bit more of a vague feel — more toward Zen Arcade and away from Tommy. That’s where the line is drawn for me.
Jane, I’m thinking about posting it as a playlist when it’s done. I’d love to share what I’ve been working on with such an important group of people as you, the Whatsitsers.
Sweet. I’m really looking forward to hearing it.
Hey, how come you didn’t include the cover art for your album? (Or are you saving that for a future post?)
I was saving the cover art for when I post the finished record as a playlist.
I can’t wait to hear the final album.