They say you are who you are by the age of three. My grooves were formed to a Martin four-string guitar. I fetched the case, set it down gently and lifted the top without touching the instrument inside. Only my father could pick it up and sling the strap across his shoulders, resting the cherry wood curves on his lap. He curled around the small body and dislodged a pick from the neck. He let me pluck the strings and we chanted “my dog has fleas” as he twisted the knobs to find the right sound. My mother carefully slid a record from the cover, balancing on just her fingertips, a steadying thumb on the paper label. She placed it on the spindle and floated the needle at the edge with sacred gravity. This was our text.
My father picked tunes late into the night, The Weavers Songbook propped open on the floor. His whiskey tenor discovered verse after verse until my mother finally went to bed. I sat awake, listening. The music seeped into the air and clung to my face, my clothing, my way in the world. I absorbed every refrain.
Our family tree was common and hard working, enduring poverty but dependent on no one’s charity. We tended orchards, herded sheep and worked for the railroads. An inherited pride echoed through my parents’ fierce response to authority and privilege. They were tough kids and their music was defiant. They identified with songs about overcoming oppression; themes carried from homelands in Europe and Africa to new relevance in Appalachia and the Deep South. These songs expressed collective sorrow and inspired activism. Together they dreamed of freedom; freedom from fear, from judgment, from the limits of their background. I accepted the weight of this hope as my own, a desire for change so strong that I counted the freight train cars from behind the guardrail, wondering what it would be to ride the rails away from here, to heaven, to the next town.
I learned stories from the songs and I learned the songs for the stories. I knew all their names: John Martin, John Henry, Pretty Boy Floyd, Frankie, Old Blue, Barbry Allen, Willy, Polly, Johnny, Jackaroe. I knew who they loved and who they killed and was never frightened by the violence. These narrators did not talk down to me. They knew that children, living in a world filled with taunts and commands and confusion, were closer to the heart of these stories than tidy, disapproving adults. I gravitated toward the saddest voices raw with pain, foregoing barroom ditties to keen around the campfire with a silver dagger clutched in my imagination. I was young, but I knew light and dark. I knew love and hate. I recognized the ancient drumbeat coda that stirs our passion and clouds our sense. The invoked warnings organized a kind of morality: there, but for the grace of God, go all of us.
I grew older. My parents grew tamer. I learned the rules to being a good girl, shellacked in appropriate behavior. But under the surface was always the music, wails of pure emotion cradled by banjo or mandolin. I collected songs and singers who preserved the history of wild people; people put down and flawed, aching in love and loss, resolute in the joyful howl of life. These singers once sat at the foot of a chair and stayed awake. Someone said to them: this is yours to tell and you must tell it or it will be forgotten. Verse, refrain, verse. This is our voice, my voice, and it breaks through the shell and is loud and messy and true. I am the witness now. My memory sings of a young man in a white t-shirt, hunched over a small guitar, angry, soothed, sharing a past that will fade for him and root deeply within the child who listens, still.


I loved this postscript to your playlist yesterday. I’m always struck by the way your parents, perhaps because they started so young, really belonged to a different culture when you were born than they eventually grew into as full-blown adults, and by the fact that you were able to make that movement toward modernity with them — to be somewhat self-aware about what was going on. Is upward mobility inimical to protest songs and old hillbilly ballads? Does the “tamer” version of your dad ever break out a guitar and sing from the Weavers Songbook?
favorite line: I recognized the ancient drumbeat coda that stirs our passion and clouds our sense.
Bryan – he does still play the Martin now and then – when I am visiting mostly. It is the only thing I have asked for in his will, although he claims he will outlive me because my eating habits are similar to mountain people as well. I had sausage gravy and bisquits for breakfast yesterday while contemplating these posts. Coincidence? I don’t think so.
Pandora, this is lovely. Thanks for this and the playlist. It’ll be interesting to see how your kids, who seem to have a very different relationship to these songs, will respond to “Mom’s wailing music” in 20 years.
One of my favorite memories of the last 10 year came during one of our old annual camping trips — Pandora singing a ballad at the campfire — something wicked about the singer having sex with the devil or something like that — and her being slightly worried that the kids were still awake in their tents and able to hear the whole thing …
Something that occurred to me when I was rereading this was how there’s this music that usually passes for rebellious, bad-boy/girl music that kids get into, and it’s rock music, or maybe hip hop. But you can make the argument that rock and hip hop are so suburbanized and commodified that they’re perfectly safe — suburban rebellion, nothing more. (Hip hop being more complicated, of course, because a lot of it really comes from “the streets” but is appropriated by suburban kids.) Which leaves unpopular musics, including this old murdery stuff, untouched by the Starbucksification of rebellion and thus really much more frightening, potentially.
(Sorry, end of day, end of week, not very coherent.)
so early in the year to be posting your best of 2008! that’s not to underestimate your future posts, but I doubt you or anyone could top this prose!
beautiful prose, pandora.
and we loved the mix. thank you.
trixie
I love the prose, too, PB. Add my melody to the refrain of praises.